![]() The stone which was set at nought by the scientific builders of the nineteenth century is become the head of the corner. We have found a need for dialectic, for the logic of philosophy. ![]() Mathematical discoveries, which have caused a revolution in our mode of conceiving the physical universe, and the discoveries of the new psychology, which have profoundly changed our mode of conceiving the mind, have necessitated a reconsideration of what is implied in the experimental method. ![]() It is a living work to-day because, more than at any previous time, the problem of the methodology of science is in the forefront. The process as a whole he called the dialectical process, or just the dialectic, and he analysed it as made up of three main stages. What is the rational kernel of Hegels dialectic that Marx famously speaks of How can it be extracted from the mystical shell in which it is embedded in. Most of this book was originally presented in papers read and discussed at the Aristotelian Society in the early 'nineties and published in Mind, for at that time the Society did not publish Proceedings. The Hegelian Dialectic originated with George Wilhelm Friedrich Hegel (1770-1831), a nineteenth century school teacher, philosopher. His own view would seem to be that the ultimate reality is a unity of personalities, but that this unity is not itself a personality. The pattern of Problem-Reaction-Solution is The Hegelian Dialectic, a repeating pattern that plays out in reality: 1) Create a problem, 2) Foment a reaction (of anger or sympathy), and 3) Roll out the solution. McTaggart reaches would be accepted probably even by the most convinced Hegelians, namely, the conclusion that the logic is of permanent value and the dialectic sound, but that the metaphysic is unsatisfactory and cannot be final. Then the process starts all over again: Thesis vs. 3) Conflict between the two forces results in the forming of a synthesis. It contains the best exposition of the dialectic, and the best defence of the dialectic, and the best criticism of it by any living writer. In Hegelian terms, 1) an existing force (the thesis) 2) generates a counter-force (the antithesis). McTaggart's Hook on its first appearance now lays it down, having read it again from beginning to end. (Americans understood man’s spiritual quests to be outside the realm of government control). This is the feeling with which one who read Dr. Studies in the Hegelian Dialectic by McTaggart John McTaggart Ellis from . The Hegelian dialectic is the ridiculous idea that constant conflict and continual merging of opposite ideologies, as established by extreme right or left belief systems, will lead spiritual mankind into final perfection. IT is curious that a book which professed only to be a study of Hegel, and deals with criticisms of the Hegelian method and principle current more than thirty years ago, should be reprinted to-day and present the same freshness and vigour to the reader now as it did then.
0 Comments
Leave a Reply. |
AuthorWrite something about yourself. No need to be fancy, just an overview. ArchivesCategories |